You've posted this numerous times about Jones between this thread and the Aaron Jones thread. I don't personally understand your stance, and I've yet to see you back it up with anything more than a shrug and "I see what I see" mentality.
@Biabreakable, one of the most respected posters on this board IMO, has even tried to pull it out of you clarifying what you've said -- all without much luck.
You've stumped for Williams repeatedly as this stud who's super physical, but Jones is listed by the team at 5'9" 208 and Williams at 6'0" 213. That's a BMI of 30.7 for Jones to 28.9 for Williams. Both are certainly in the acceptable range, but that doesn't make Williams this physical feature back and Jones some scat back. The data actually suggests Jones is thicker.
You've repeatedly knock Jones for a lack of elusiveness and a lack of home run speed (or what you call being a "home run hitter"), but ignore the fact that Jones blasted Williams in nearly every combine drill. I certainly understand the Combine isn't a replacement for film, but I don't see what you're saying on film either.
6.82 3-Cone to Williams' Yeti-like 7.25
4.20 Short Shuttle to Williams' 4.53
4.49 40-Yard to Williams' 4.59
1.51 10-yard split to Williams' 1.60
The data certainly doesn't suggest that Jones lacks elusiveness or breakaway ability (what I assume you mean by being a "home run hitter"). If anything, he's far closer to that than Williams. But somehow Williams doesn't get penalized for his subpar athleticism in the same way you're trying to discount Jones. Instead Williams is a future feature back?
Per Football Outsiders, Jones outpaces Williams in Defense-adjusted Yards Above Replacement 109-34. If he had just 10 more carries to qualify for the full list, he'd rank 6th in all of the NFL, tied with Alex Collins, just ahead of Howard and Fournette, and behind only Elliott, Hunt, Ingram, Freeman, and Bell. Full Disclosure, if Kamara (needs 16 more carries) and Dion Lewis (needs 8 more carries), qualified for the list, they'd rank ahead of Jones too. Williams' 34 would rank 17th. That certainly doesn't suggest Williams is awful, but it's also a sample of 31 carries. Perhaps he moves up the list, or perhaps he falls way down the list.
Football Outsiders says DYAR measures overall value while DVOA measures value per play. In DVOA, Aaron Jones posts a 25.5%, a figure that would rank 3rd in the league (minimum of 50 carries) behind only Kamara and Lewis.
Aaron Jones is really good. I don't really know how else to explain it ...