White is easily better than Jacobs in my opinion
Because?
I gave my reasons why I think JJ is better right now.
First, White is by far the better athlete. Jacobs ran a 4.64 forty at his pro day, which typically translates to a 4.69 at the combine. His broad jump was also pedestrian at 9’4”. White ran a 4.40 flat and had a 10’8 broad jump at the combine(elite). Jacobs and White are roughly the same size.
Jacobs played three years at Alabama with Damien Harris. Harris had better rushing numbers all three years and had a better athletic profile based on his combine measurements. Jacobs did have better numbers in the passing game though.
Even as high schoolers, Zamir was a 5 star prospect, Jacobs was a 3 star prospect.
IMO Jacobs was over-drafted. His 1st round draft capital got him plenty of run, but he is not that dude.
Cool.
I agree with practically everything you typed.
White is the better athlete based on testing.
and JJ was over drafted, no doubt
I think JJ has looser hips, established hands, pass block chops and the experience gained from 3 yrs in the league.
I don’t NOT LIKE White at all. He does everything I would want in a committee.
I just think that he is raw, doesn’t keep his eyes up enough, has The same gap/zone limitations as JJ
and runs right into people on the second level at times.
I expect all those things to improve as he gets his time in the league.
Let me ask you. Would you trade JJ for White straight up?