2QB Dyno question (1 Viewer)

[xpiredcoupon]

Rank these trade offer opportunities:

This is for a 2QB dyno that I am. I am the defending champ but I am trying to trade away Julio/AJ Green a year or 2 early before it is a year or 2 late. Would you do any of the trades listed (1, 2 or all 3) or would you pass because DHOP is just that unmovable of a player. Rosters and starting lineup requirements are as listed below:

PPR: 2QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1RWT FLEX

My Roster:

QB: Cam Newton, Jimmy Garoppalo, Dak Prescott, Andy Dalton

RB: Todd Gurley, Leonard Fournette, Christian McCaffrey, Jerrick McKinnon, Mark Ingram, Kenyon Drake, Duke Johnson

WR: Julio Jones, AJ Green, Mike Thomas, Tyreek Hill, Sammy Watkins, Josh Doctson, Mike Wallace (soon to be cut)

TE: Jimmy Graham, David Njoku

His Roster:

QB: Aaron Rodgers, Case Keenum, Eli Manning, Jay Cutler (probably being cut but not if he comes back because oddly enough he is a big Jay Cutler fanboy)

RB: Devonta Freeman, Isiah Crowell, Marshawn Lynch, Doug Martin, Orleans Darkwa, Mike Davis, Peyton Barber, Tion Green (kind of weak at RB)

WR: Deandre Hopkins, Adam Theilen, Larry Fitzgerald, Jamison Crowder,  Nelson Agholer, Rishard Matthews, Trent Taylor

TE: Rob Gronkowski, Jack Doyle

Offer Idea #1: Julio Jones and AJ Green for Deandre Hopkins 

My impression is that he is aware that Julio and AJ are getting older but this is still a strong offer. He is ok at WR and needs help at RB so I would like it if he would warm up to offers such as:

Offer Idea #2: AJ Green, Christian McCaffery, and Andy Dalton for Deandre Hopkins and Larry Fitzgerald 

Realistically I would do this without Larry but if I could get him as a throw in I would be very happy with that as I still expect Larry to have a top 16 season this year.

Offer Idea #3: Julio Jones and Jerrick McKinnon OR Kenyon Drake for Deandre Hopkins

Any thoughts on any of these 3 trades OR if you have a better offer I should send I would greatly appreciate. PLEASE leave your links for your questions if you have any as well. It is early enough in the offseason before draft season that I think we can help each other out with DYNO help.

THANKS!

 

[snoochieboochies]

Offer 3 is my favorite. Due to the lineup you can set, I like moving 1 non starting RB and a WR. I doubt he will buy Julio and Drake, but Julio and McKinnon is a maybe. 

 

[Gally]

No way I do Offer #1.  That is too much to give up.  Jones and AJG are still top WR's and expect them to stay for a couple more years at least. 

Offer #2 is good for you but I doubt he takes it. 

Offer #3 is also good for you if it is Drake.  I wouldn't hesitate to give up McKinnon but I think he is line for a big year.  I wouldn't fault you for doing the deal but I wouldn't do it.

 

[beerbuff]

If I were the opposing team I would take #1, I'd pass on #2 and I would seriously consider #3. So start with # 2, move to #3 and then do #1 as a last resort

 

[msudaisy26]

If I were the opposing team I would take #1, I'd pass on #2 and I would seriously consider #3. So start with # 2, move to #3 and then do #1 as a last resort

This is a good post except I wouldn't do 1 no matter what.

 

[xpiredcoupon]

No way I do Offer #1.  That is too much to give up.  Jones and AJG are still top WR's and expect them to stay for a couple more years at least. 

Offer #2 is good for you but I doubt he takes it. 

Offer #3 is also good for you if it is Drake.  I wouldn't hesitate to give up McKinnon but I think he is line for a big year.  I wouldn't fault you for doing the deal but I wouldn't do it.

I like the idea of moving a player a year early rather than a year late because of players values falling off a cliff. nuk is 5 years younger than those guys with a stud young qb at the helm. Do I really want to trade away julio and aj who just helped me win a championship? Not particularly but I see Nuk or Odell as a right price type player to justify a move like that.

 

[Gally]

I like the idea of moving a player a year early rather than a year late because of players values falling off a cliff. nuk is 5 years younger than those guys with a stud young qb at the helm. Do I really want to trade away julio and aj who just helped me win a championship? Not particularly but I see Nuk or Odell as a right price type player to justify a move like that.

The point is to win and I think that trade would hurt your team for the next couple years.  I understand the concept of trading a piece a year earlier than later but Wr's hold their value better than most positions.  I also don't see these two guys at the end of there usefullness.

 

[RoninJT]

Offer #1 is flat out a terrible trade for you. 

Offer #2 is a good trade but only because of your depth. He's getting better overall value but the improvement to your starting line-up is comparable. 

Offer #3 is a good trade.