How high do you have MJH in dynasty WR rankings?
Top-10 easily. Probably depends on team build for a couple cases, so I'd say roughly WR7.
That makes sense. I think Jefferson, Chase, CeeDee and the
Browns have to be above Marv. After that, it gets interesting.
Not for me, especially AJB.
And fwiw I offered ASB for 1.1 awhile ago, had some other small stuff in it, but got rejected and told it was not for sale so the other stuff was not the issue. I'm actually ok with that rejection, was a little unsure of it when I made it, part of it was also trying to create some roster space which I've since done. So that's a tough call between those two, I'd lean having the 1.1 though, a little easy call for me vs AJB who I'd also take Nabers over.
I think he did you a favor. I love MHJ as much as the next guy, but if he becomes ASB then he’s doing pretty damn well.
Yeah that trade would be the epitome of the family guy mystery box meme "A boats a boat, but the mystery box could be anything! It could even be a boat!"
Appreciate the input, don't want to clog this thread but will point out there was a little more to my thought process.
First got to say I had a huge goal of clearing roster space, had several players I wanted to keep and it was actually stressing me a little I had to cut them if I could not work it out. So to begin with ASB for 1.1 was going to allow me to keep a player I was looking at cutting. I mentioned "there was some other small stuff" in the trade ,maybe I undersold it and it was a little bigger then small stuff. It's a TEP league and I noticed the team was pretty weak at TE, so part of my offer was including Likely for his 2.4 and I think I was throwing in a mid round pick, can't remember, something like a late 4th I think.
Likely is someone I had designated to keep, and did end up keeping after we had to cut down to 14 position players, but I had 4-5 players I liked just a little less then him I wanted to keep I was faced with cutting and would have been happy to turn him into a draft pick and keep one of the other players. So to me the basis of the trade was not just ASB for 1.1 but creating two extra roster spots and obtaining a solid 2.4 pick.
Now that was my offer and the team I made the offer to had just bought the team. Had he countered asking to remove the LIkely/2.4 part would I have done it? I had not made up my mind yet, would have tried to work in one of those cuts I had for a third or something but if not was leaning straight up ASB for 1.1 in part on idea it would create at least one extra roster spot. But the guy just told me he thought my offer was interesting and fair, but he bought the team specifically to draft MHJ and that was that.
Now also this trade offer was made in January or early February, can't recall exacty but when it was assumed Ben Johnson was leaving. I'm worried about that impact, if I recall ASB broke out his rookie season when Ben Johnson started to have more say in the offense. I'm worried specficaly even with Johnson remaining but especialy so if he leaves that there are to many mouths to feed for ASB to continue being among the top target leaders in the league as I expect second year Laporta and Gibbs roles to increase, as well as ome others. Statisical growth is not always linear as we know. ASB went from about 16 fantasy points a game to 20.5. I guess I have my doubts, especially without Ben Johnson, he remains in that realm and fear he's more likely to decrease a little.
Saying all that even now that Ben Johnson has returned there have been 8 startups with first round data from the last week in this format and ASB is going 5 and MHJ is 6. So again looking at this back when I thought Johnson was exiting and either creating 1 or 2 roster spots and/or picking up a nice pick made sense to me, and still does.
I'm good with the rejection, especialy now because I managed to clear some of that roster space and added 1.1 in another leauge for a lot less then what I was offering here and have now reached a point where I'm no longer trying to buy 1.1 since I've obtained in 3 leagues. Also my team is a contender and I would have viewed ASB to MHJ as a step back in year one.
Just explaining my thought process.