I should begin this by totally agreeing, that in normal situations, a hit rate on players outside the top thirty seems very small. I'm not sure the numbers, but they're low. FantasyPros did great work on stuff like this; I wish I had it offhand or memorized. But yeah, your point is taken.
And I like him as a player, so that's not totally the issue. The issue is that there's a problem with my personal opinion about liking him as a player. I'm enamored of speed. He didn't have a ton to begin with. That's sort of a negative mark in my book. I rostered him last year. Before the draft, I shipped him for a first-round pick, Dallas Goedert, and a second round pick or something like that. I forget the third thing. Think it was a second rounder. But I dealt him because I wasn't enamored of his speed. More importantly, I knew Urban Meyer wasn't because he said so as soon as he took the reins to the squad. So I dumped him for that kitty plus the thought that he'd be replaced. And he was. So I should end it there, right?
I can't though. Seeing what he did this year in the situations he was given a chance changed my mind about him as a player. Or the announcers' excitement changed my mind. Or the story did. Or Urban's utter jackassery. Whatever the case, my mind was changed. And now that said, but now you have to factor in his loss of speed he didn't have to lose because of the difficulty fully recovering, and you've got a major problem in my problem, because my evaluation has changed because of his results and vision and burst, but now a big part of all that is compromised tremendously.
So there you have my thought process on him. One last thing...
Plus he's a UFA after next year and the league moves so quickly. He's going to have to prove himself all over again to a team, and who knows if he'll pick the right one or if the right one will want him. That's why, given my league (51 man rosters, IDP league - typical Zealots league) I might not pay a third for him, and would maybe (I probably likely would) value him as a fourth. With a third round pick I can pick somebody on defense or at LB or DE, two positions of need in that league.