Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
Post your 2024 dynasty rookie drafts (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter chook
- Start date
KellysHeroes
Footballguy
Damm, Daniels is always going in the 1st
Traded my 2025 1st and 3.08 to get him at 1.14 (1 QB/14 Team IDP)
Traded my 2025 1st and 3.08 to get him at 1.14 (1 QB/14 Team IDP)
smbkrypt24
Footballguy
Is that your personal goal or what you have seen in recent drafts?
KellysHeroes
Footballguy
what I've seen
osubuckeyeman
Footballguy
Those are challenging moves to make. Were you not able to wait until your partner was OTC? I'm sure you have a fallback plan.
joey
Footballguy
Confirmation bias abounds for me in this thread…
See a dude I drafted go before or right around the same place I picked him: I rule. My rankings and logic were sound.
See a dude I drafted go multiple picks after where I picked him: Outlier. Disregard that crappy, newb league of guppies.
See a dude I drafted go before or right around the same place I picked him: I rule. My rankings and logic were sound.
See a dude I drafted go multiple picks after where I picked him: Outlier. Disregard that crappy, newb league of guppies.
massraider
Footballguy
KellysHeroes
Footballguy
McCarthy was taken 1.08 / Caleb was taken 1.13 and I have very little interest in Nix or Maye... I'm sure JD was going to be taken early 2nd
I was lucky to get back in the 2nd to secure Corum who was actually my second choice at 1.14 (Williams owner here)
Lehigh98
Footballguy
12 Team SF, 0.5 ppr, TEP 1.0 ppr, 0.25 ppc
PICK PLAYER
1.01 Williams, Caleb CHI QB (R)
1.02 Harrison Jr., Marvin ARI WR (R)
1.03 Daniels, Jayden WAS QB (R)
1.04 Nabers, Malik NYG WR (R)
1.05 Bowers, Brock LVR TE (R) (Q)
1.06 McCarthy, J.J. MIN QB (R)
1.07 Maye, Drake NEP QB (R)
1.08 Odunze, Rome CHI WR (R)
1.09 Thomas Jr., Brian JAC WR (R)
1.10 Nix, Bo DEN QB (R)
1.11 Worthy, Xavier KCC WR (R)
1.12 Coleman, Keon BUF WR (R)
2.01 Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB (R) (Q)
2.02 McConkey, Ladd LAC WR (R)
2.03 Sinnott, Ben WAS TE (R)
2.04 Benson, Trey ARI RB (R)
2.05 Penix Jr., Michael ATL QB (R)
2.06 Legette, Xavier CAR WR (R)
2.07 Corum, Blake LAR RB (R)
2.08 Pearsall, Ricky SFO WR (R)
2.09 Wilson, Roman PIT WR (R)
2.10 Mitchell, Adonai IND WR (R)
2.11 Wright, Jaylen MIA RB (R)
2.12 McCaffrey, Luke WAS WR (R)
3.01 Franklin, Troy DEN WR (R)
3.02 Lloyd, MarShawn GBP RB (R)
3.03 Burton, Jermaine CIN WR (R)
3.04 Sanders, Ja'Tavion CAR TE (R)
3.05 Polk, Ja'Lynn NEP WR (R)
3.06 Rattler, Spencer NOS QB (R)
3.07 Corley, Malachi NYJ WR (R)
3.08 Davis, Ray BUF RB (R)
3.09 Vidal, Kimani LAC RB (R)
3.10 Irving, Bucky TBB RB (R)
3.11 McMillan, Jalen TBB WR (R)
3.12 Baker, Javon NEP WR (R)
4.01 Estime, Audric DEN RB (R)
4.02 Allen, Braelon NYJ RB (R)
4.03 All, Erick CIN TE (R) (Q)
4.04 Johnson, Theo NYG TE (R)
4.05 Shipley, Will PHI RB (R)
4.06 Washington, Malik MIA WR (R)
4.07 Tracy, Tyrone NYG RB (R)
4.08 Guerendo, Isaac SFO RB (R)
4.09 Wiley, Jared KCC TE (R)
4.10 Rice, Brenden LAC WR (R)
4.11 Walker, Devontez BAL WR (R)
4.12 Smith, Ainias PHI WR (R)
PICK PLAYER
1.01 Williams, Caleb CHI QB (R)
1.02 Harrison Jr., Marvin ARI WR (R)
1.03 Daniels, Jayden WAS QB (R)
1.04 Nabers, Malik NYG WR (R)
1.05 Bowers, Brock LVR TE (R) (Q)
1.06 McCarthy, J.J. MIN QB (R)
1.07 Maye, Drake NEP QB (R)
1.08 Odunze, Rome CHI WR (R)
1.09 Thomas Jr., Brian JAC WR (R)
1.10 Nix, Bo DEN QB (R)
1.11 Worthy, Xavier KCC WR (R)
1.12 Coleman, Keon BUF WR (R)
2.01 Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB (R) (Q)
2.02 McConkey, Ladd LAC WR (R)
2.03 Sinnott, Ben WAS TE (R)
2.04 Benson, Trey ARI RB (R)
2.05 Penix Jr., Michael ATL QB (R)
2.06 Legette, Xavier CAR WR (R)
2.07 Corum, Blake LAR RB (R)
2.08 Pearsall, Ricky SFO WR (R)
2.09 Wilson, Roman PIT WR (R)
2.10 Mitchell, Adonai IND WR (R)
2.11 Wright, Jaylen MIA RB (R)
2.12 McCaffrey, Luke WAS WR (R)
3.01 Franklin, Troy DEN WR (R)
3.02 Lloyd, MarShawn GBP RB (R)
3.03 Burton, Jermaine CIN WR (R)
3.04 Sanders, Ja'Tavion CAR TE (R)
3.05 Polk, Ja'Lynn NEP WR (R)
3.06 Rattler, Spencer NOS QB (R)
3.07 Corley, Malachi NYJ WR (R)
3.08 Davis, Ray BUF RB (R)
3.09 Vidal, Kimani LAC RB (R)
3.10 Irving, Bucky TBB RB (R)
3.11 McMillan, Jalen TBB WR (R)
3.12 Baker, Javon NEP WR (R)
4.01 Estime, Audric DEN RB (R)
4.02 Allen, Braelon NYJ RB (R)
4.03 All, Erick CIN TE (R) (Q)
4.04 Johnson, Theo NYG TE (R)
4.05 Shipley, Will PHI RB (R)
4.06 Washington, Malik MIA WR (R)
4.07 Tracy, Tyrone NYG RB (R)
4.08 Guerendo, Isaac SFO RB (R)
4.09 Wiley, Jared KCC TE (R)
4.10 Rice, Brenden LAC WR (R)
4.11 Walker, Devontez BAL WR (R)
4.12 Smith, Ainias PHI WR (R)
Lehigh98
Footballguy
24 team, 2 copy league, SF, TEP, devy (one copy can be picked as devy, one remains until they're drafted into the NFL)
1.01 was me, contender, acquired via trade, loaded at QB (Burrow, Herbert, Richardson, Daniels) and no one would trade so took MHJ
1.02 and 1.03 doesn't understand SF or know what he's doing. (You'll see he's maybe not the only one.)
PICK PLAYER
1.01 Harrison Jr., Marvin ARI WR (R)
1.02 Nabers, Malik NYG WR (R)
1.03 Odunze, Rome CHI WR (R)
1.04 Williams, Caleb CHI QB (R)
1.05 Daniels, Jayden WAS QB (R)
1.06 Coleman, Keon BUF WR (R)
1.07 McCarthy, J.J. MIN QB (R)
1.08 Maye, Drake NEP QB (R)
1.09 Bowers, Brock LVR TE (R) (Q)
1.10 Worthy, Xavier KCC WR (R)
1.11 Nix, Bo DEN QB (R)
1.12 Penix Jr., Michael ATL QB (R)
1.13 Coleman, Keon BUF WR (R)
1.14 Thomas Jr., Brian JAC WR (R)
1.15 Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB (R) (Q)
1.16 Thomas Jr., Brian JAC WR (R)
1.17 Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB (R) (Q)
1.18 * *McMillan, Tetairoa, 2025 FA WR (R)
1.19 * *Beck, Carson, 2025 FA QB (R)
1.20 McConkey, Ladd LAC WR (R)
1.21 Mitchell, Adonai IND WR (R)
1.22 McConkey, Ladd LAC WR (R)
1.23 Benson, Trey ARI RB (R)
1.24 Corum, Blake LAR RB (R)
1.25 Benson, Trey ARI RB (R)
2.01 Wright, Jaylen MIA RB (R)
2.02 Stover, Cade HOU TE (R)
2.03 Pearsall, Ricky SFO WR (R)
2.04 Legette, Xavier CAR WR (R)
2.05 Sinnott, Ben WAS TE (R)
2.06 Wilson, Roman PIT WR (R)
2.07 Stover, Cade HOU TE (R)
2.08 * *Gordon , Ollie, 2025 FA RB (R)
2.09 Pearsall, Ricky SFO WR (R)
2.10 Washington, Malik MIA WR (R)
2.11 McCaffrey, Luke WAS WR (R)
2.12 McCaffrey, Luke WAS WR (R)
2.13 Wright, Jaylen MIA RB (R)
2.14 Rattler, Spencer NOS QB (R)
2.15 * *Loveland, Colston, 2025 FA TE (R)
2.16 Lloyd, MarShawn GBP RB (R)
2.17 Wilson, Roman PIT WR (R)
2.18 * *Iamaleava, Nico, 2026 FA QB (R)
2.19 Mitchell, Adonai IND WR (R)
2.20 Sinnott, Ben WAS TE (R)
2.21 Legette, Xavier CAR WR (R)
2.22 * *Bond, Isaiah, 2025 FA WR (R)
2.23 Sanders, Ja'Tavion CAR TE (R)
2.24 Polk, Ja'Lynn NEP WR (R)
3.01 Corley, Malachi NYJ WR (R)
3.02 Davis, Ray BUF RB (R)
3.03 Lloyd, MarShawn GBP RB (R)
3.04 Polk, Ja'Lynn NEP WR (R)
3.05 * *Manning, Arch, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.06 Davis, Ray BUF RB (R)
3.07 Irving, Bucky TBB RB (R)
3.08 Franklin, Troy DEN WR (R)
3.09 * *Baxter, CJ, 2026 FA RB (R)
3.10 Shipley, Will PHI RB (R)
3.11 Burton, Jermaine CIN WR (R)
3.12 Tracy, Tyrone NYG RB (R)
3.13 * *Moore, Dante, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.14 * *Arnold, Jackson, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.15 * *Tate, Carnell, 2026 FA WR (R)
3.16 Ali, Rasheen BAL RB (R) (Q)
3.17 * *Milroe, Jalen, 2025 FA QB (R)
3.18 * *Branch, Zachariah, 2026 FA WR (R)
3.19 Corley, Malachi NYJ WR (R)
3.20 * *Nelson, Malachi, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.21 * *Neal, Devin, 2025 FA RB (R)
3.22 * *Hampton, Omarion, 2025 FA RB (R)
3.23 Baker, Javon NEP WR (R)
3.24 Baker, Javon NEP WR (R)
1.01 was me, contender, acquired via trade, loaded at QB (Burrow, Herbert, Richardson, Daniels) and no one would trade so took MHJ
1.02 and 1.03 doesn't understand SF or know what he's doing. (You'll see he's maybe not the only one.)
PICK PLAYER
1.01 Harrison Jr., Marvin ARI WR (R)
1.02 Nabers, Malik NYG WR (R)
1.03 Odunze, Rome CHI WR (R)
1.04 Williams, Caleb CHI QB (R)
1.05 Daniels, Jayden WAS QB (R)
1.06 Coleman, Keon BUF WR (R)
1.07 McCarthy, J.J. MIN QB (R)
1.08 Maye, Drake NEP QB (R)
1.09 Bowers, Brock LVR TE (R) (Q)
1.10 Worthy, Xavier KCC WR (R)
1.11 Nix, Bo DEN QB (R)
1.12 Penix Jr., Michael ATL QB (R)
1.13 Coleman, Keon BUF WR (R)
1.14 Thomas Jr., Brian JAC WR (R)
1.15 Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB (R) (Q)
1.16 Thomas Jr., Brian JAC WR (R)
1.17 Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB (R) (Q)
1.18 * *McMillan, Tetairoa, 2025 FA WR (R)
1.19 * *Beck, Carson, 2025 FA QB (R)
1.20 McConkey, Ladd LAC WR (R)
1.21 Mitchell, Adonai IND WR (R)
1.22 McConkey, Ladd LAC WR (R)
1.23 Benson, Trey ARI RB (R)
1.24 Corum, Blake LAR RB (R)
1.25 Benson, Trey ARI RB (R)
2.01 Wright, Jaylen MIA RB (R)
2.02 Stover, Cade HOU TE (R)
2.03 Pearsall, Ricky SFO WR (R)
2.04 Legette, Xavier CAR WR (R)
2.05 Sinnott, Ben WAS TE (R)
2.06 Wilson, Roman PIT WR (R)
2.07 Stover, Cade HOU TE (R)
2.08 * *Gordon , Ollie, 2025 FA RB (R)
2.09 Pearsall, Ricky SFO WR (R)
2.10 Washington, Malik MIA WR (R)
2.11 McCaffrey, Luke WAS WR (R)
2.12 McCaffrey, Luke WAS WR (R)
2.13 Wright, Jaylen MIA RB (R)
2.14 Rattler, Spencer NOS QB (R)
2.15 * *Loveland, Colston, 2025 FA TE (R)
2.16 Lloyd, MarShawn GBP RB (R)
2.17 Wilson, Roman PIT WR (R)
2.18 * *Iamaleava, Nico, 2026 FA QB (R)
2.19 Mitchell, Adonai IND WR (R)
2.20 Sinnott, Ben WAS TE (R)
2.21 Legette, Xavier CAR WR (R)
2.22 * *Bond, Isaiah, 2025 FA WR (R)
2.23 Sanders, Ja'Tavion CAR TE (R)
2.24 Polk, Ja'Lynn NEP WR (R)
3.01 Corley, Malachi NYJ WR (R)
3.02 Davis, Ray BUF RB (R)
3.03 Lloyd, MarShawn GBP RB (R)
3.04 Polk, Ja'Lynn NEP WR (R)
3.05 * *Manning, Arch, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.06 Davis, Ray BUF RB (R)
3.07 Irving, Bucky TBB RB (R)
3.08 Franklin, Troy DEN WR (R)
3.09 * *Baxter, CJ, 2026 FA RB (R)
3.10 Shipley, Will PHI RB (R)
3.11 Burton, Jermaine CIN WR (R)
3.12 Tracy, Tyrone NYG RB (R)
3.13 * *Moore, Dante, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.14 * *Arnold, Jackson, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.15 * *Tate, Carnell, 2026 FA WR (R)
3.16 Ali, Rasheen BAL RB (R) (Q)
3.17 * *Milroe, Jalen, 2025 FA QB (R)
3.18 * *Branch, Zachariah, 2026 FA WR (R)
3.19 Corley, Malachi NYJ WR (R)
3.20 * *Nelson, Malachi, 2026 FA QB (R)
3.21 * *Neal, Devin, 2025 FA RB (R)
3.22 * *Hampton, Omarion, 2025 FA RB (R)
3.23 Baker, Javon NEP WR (R)
3.24 Baker, Javon NEP WR (R)
Last edited:
TartanLion
Footballguy
12 team SF 0.5 ppr 1.75 TE premium
1.01. Caleb Williams
1.02 Marvin Harrison Jnr
1.03. Jalen Daniels
1.04. Malik Nabers
1.05. JJ McCarthy
1.06. Drake Maye
1.07. Brock Bowers
1.08. Rome Odunze
1.09. Xavier Worthy
1.10. Jonathon Brooks
1.11. Trey Benson
1.12. Brian Thomas
2.01. Bo Nix
2.02. Michael Penix Jnr
2.03. Ladd McConkey
2.04. Keon Coleman
2.05. Xavier Legette
2.06.Ricky Pearsall
2.07. Ben Sinnott
2.08. Ja’Lynn Polk
2.09. Jermaine Burton
2.10. Blake Corum ( me and I’m the Kyren owner)
2.11. Troy Franklin
2.12. AD Mitchell
3.01. Ja’Tavion Sanders
3.02. MarShawn Lloyd
3.03. Jalen Wright
3.04. Roman Wilson ( me )
3.05. Bucky Irving
3.06. Malachi Corley
3.07. Javon Baker
3.08. Spencer Rattler
3.09. Devontez Walker
To be completed
1.01. Caleb Williams
1.02 Marvin Harrison Jnr
1.03. Jalen Daniels
1.04. Malik Nabers
1.05. JJ McCarthy
1.06. Drake Maye
1.07. Brock Bowers
1.08. Rome Odunze
1.09. Xavier Worthy
1.10. Jonathon Brooks
1.11. Trey Benson
1.12. Brian Thomas
2.01. Bo Nix
2.02. Michael Penix Jnr
2.03. Ladd McConkey
2.04. Keon Coleman
2.05. Xavier Legette
2.06.Ricky Pearsall
2.07. Ben Sinnott
2.08. Ja’Lynn Polk
2.09. Jermaine Burton
2.10. Blake Corum ( me and I’m the Kyren owner)
2.11. Troy Franklin
2.12. AD Mitchell
3.01. Ja’Tavion Sanders
3.02. MarShawn Lloyd
3.03. Jalen Wright
3.04. Roman Wilson ( me )
3.05. Bucky Irving
3.06. Malachi Corley
3.07. Javon Baker
3.08. Spencer Rattler
3.09. Devontez Walker
To be completed
Last edited:
Rirruto
Footballguy
What's the value like for Arch at 3.05? Seems like the 1.04 had to do cartwheels for getting Caleb, but Arch also seems like a steal. Unless not being able to beat out a really mediocre Ewers + waiting 2 years brings his value waaay down?
steelcityman
Footballguy
They already took down the full results from my league.
Here is what I got picking from the x.12 unless noted otherwise
Nothing special, no superstars, but I can only keep 4 of these, barring trades, will need to pay attention to camps and preseason games....
Coleman
McCarthy
Estime at 3.3
B Iriving
Theo Johnson
Flournoy
A Mattison (rookie, F/A draft)
J Bell at 7.08
J Jordan
Here is what I got picking from the x.12 unless noted otherwise
Nothing special, no superstars, but I can only keep 4 of these, barring trades, will need to pay attention to camps and preseason games....
Coleman
McCarthy
Estime at 3.3
B Iriving
Theo Johnson
Flournoy
A Mattison (rookie, F/A draft)
J Bell at 7.08
J Jordan
Lehigh98
Footballguy
That was one of my picks and it may have actually been a little early for him. I would have rather had Nico, but he went 2.18. Devy QB's can be such a crapshoot, 2-3 years ago people were fighting over guys like Spencer Rattler and DJU and where are those guys now? Last year Allar and Klubnik went in the 2nd round and that's not looking great at the moment. Right now, I don't even have Arch at the top of that class but took him based on name value which I think I can get value on from some guys in my league when he starts playing more. Also, with him being a Manning, I'm thinking he'll get some extra chances and benefit of the doubt that other college QB's may not get, think of it like "draft capital" except that it's "Manning capital".
Similar threads
