Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
I would sell that for Williams all day long and twice on Sunday. He may not be very good in 2023, but I expect him to be fully recovered by 2024.
That’s actually kind of a bargain for JaWill.
He's not that risky.
Probably is for 2023, but not as much for 2024 hopefully.
Same injury as Dobbins, who had setbacks & required a follow-up procedure.
Let me be clear. For that price if he sat out the entire 2023 season I don't see one iota of risk.
Oh yeah - I said as much above. 2.01 + 2.11 is a potential bargain
Yeah, Goedart side for me easily. And I like Kmet.
Value wise, edge to you....but also depends on how far away on your rebuild
So this gives me a core now of:
SF I’m assuming? What picks do you have?
Completely read this as Pickett lol. Apologies.
Offered 1.07 and was rejected with no counter. He showed enough this season that he could be tough to pry away from owners.
Even coming off an ACL, I’d bet that Javonte Williams outscores any RB that falls to 2.01.
Probably so, but there’s a possibility that JaWill doesn’t fully recover. That was a fear with Dobbins until after he had his 2nd procedure.
I think generally speaking it's fairly unheard of for a young player to never recover at least pretty close to their prior form. It's just a matter of time.
I agree - but again, it wasn’t just his ACL. He reportedly dislocated his knee, and blew every tendon in the process.
I posted one awhile ago in this thread but not sure how much me saying I dealt Dulcich and a mid third for Pickens and a late 4th in a TE premium helps you set his value.
Fwiw I believe on the Dan Hindrey trade chart the value for Pickens works out exactly on par with what he put as value as rookie pick 7 in one start QB league.
I know, it was a ACL/LCL tear, same as Dobbins. I've seen nothing about every tendon though.. The Athletic Denver beat writer wrote an article when he got hurt and a doctor said it was even possible he could recover as fast a standard ACL. Like I said, it's really just a matter of time.
I'm definitely targeting him this summer, liked what I saw. Team that owns him put a TON of draft capital last year into WR and has zero RB's of note. I want to offer him 1 of R. White, K. Herbert or Allgeier + for him....just need to figure out what that plus is.
A lot cause he's worth a lot more than those guys
Guy who has him in one of my leagues told me he values him as a top 12 dynasty WR; I'd think a lot of owners are thinking that way after he flashed in his first year with average to poor QB play.
Same on my league. Dude said top 10. He gave up a ton for him.
I don’t have any shares but if people are valuing him as a top 10 dynasty WR I’d be selling.
It's fine to not agree, not sure how you can watch him play and say you don't understand it.
He definitely makes highlight catches. Don't mean to sound like Buddy Ryan talking about Cris Carter, but that's like all he does.
If you say so but he was basically productive across the board, enormously so on a per target basis.
What would you pay for him right now? Normal dynasty PPR
Very late first or early second
I see a dude who is capable of a lot. He has size, speed & crazy good hands.
he’s looked fantastic. Definitely passes the eye test.
If SF, you could be looking at a Keyshawn Boutte as the WR2 in DAL or the WR1 on the Giants. Maybe a Downs or one of the potentially elite RBs slides to 1.07, or maybe a Will Levis if you’re a believer.
Agree. Diontae is better, so you're looking at a #2 WR on a questionable passing team. If there were a top QB arriving in the near future, I'd be buying at late 1st prices. As it stands, I'd probably only pay mid-2nd.
I'd go the picks for sure. I'm not huge on Smith personally though.
The fact he did that, mainly the yardage, on 84 targets is pretty impressive to me period. To put that in perspective he had 63 targets less then Diontae and only 81 less yards and 4 MORETD's-and some of you are saying Diontae is better?.. Drake London needed 33 more targets to surpass Pickens by 65.
The problem is there's like 30 WRs in the top 12.
He was matched up with a poor QB and then a rookie QB for his rookie season. It wasn't like there was a ton of volume in that passing game.
