IMO that's lazy analysis. Quarterbacks can be gifted super bowl wins when their defense plays well. It's happened too many times to count. It happened for Eli twice. Again, crediting him for super bowl wins is just lame. Placing so much emphasis on a sample size of two is beyond stoopid (yeah, with two O's). I won't even point to his regular season record, because again, wins and losses aren't an individual statistic. Eli was never top five in any reasonable measure of comparison to his peers.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/M/MannEl00.htm
QBR? Passer rating? Approx. value? Adjusted value? In his best season he finished 7th in one of those categories.
I like that there are no fixed standards for HOF voting. I like that it's purely subjective. In my subjective opinion, he doesn't get in. However, if he does get in I won't mind because he's a former Payton award winner that played a long time and to me character counts. He plays an important role in telling the whole story of the NFL. I don't mind that the voting body has delayed entry to some players like Owens, Alex Karras, and Bob Hayes. In football players need to be accountable for how their actions impact their team and the entire league. Again, leadership and character count. Just don't try to justify his entry to the HOF based on two games. IMO that's lame.