What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Division Predictions and Win Totals: AFC East (1 Viewer)

kroyrunner89

Footballguy
We're on to Part 3 of our 8 part installment of breaking down each division for the 2010 season. As usual, win lines come from the Venetian and odds for winning the division come from sportsbook.com. This week brings us to an interesting division that should be much improved from last year, the AFC East. I believe this division may be a little more clear cut than some people think though. Here's how I see the East playing out:

* Buffalo Bills

* Win Line: 5.5

* Odds to win division: +2000 (20-1)

I think it's safe to declare the Bills dead before their season even starts. Cursed by a brutal schedule and three teams in their division that are better than them, it's hard to see how the Bills can manage a .500 record, let alone a division win. Trent Edwards remains this team's starting QB, despite having just 24 tds to 25 ints over the course of his career. Normally I'm an optimist when it comes to young quarterbacks improving as they age, however Edwards has nobody besides Lee Evans to throw the ball to now that Terrell Owens is gone. Defenses have shown in the past that they can shut Evans down, and last time he was #1 receiver on the team he only managed to score three touchdowns. The running back situation is a bit confusing right now as Marshawn Lynch is still on the team, however he's listed last on the depth chart and I assume he'll be traded before the start of the season. That leaves Fred Jackson and CJ Spiller to compete for playing time, and although I believe the presence of Spiller will help bring up the Bills' rushing numbers slightly, I doubt it'll be a dramatic improvement. With McGee still at CB the Bills should still be decent against the pass, but I expect that their #3 pass defense in yards/pass attempt will take a step back as they have big concerns at strong safety. A 6-10 team last season, I see the Bills as a team that has taken a very small step back from where they were last year. Combined with a much tougher division this year (I expect a 1-5 division record at best) and a much tougher schedule (facing the NFC North and AFC North), I see the Bills posting a dismal record and ending the year in the bottom of the AFC East.

Projected Record: 4-12

Total Play: UNDER 5.5

* Miami Dolphins

* Win Line: 8

* Odds to win division: +300 (3-1)

The 2009 Miami Dolphins struggled to a 7-9 record last season, although they were 7-7 under QB Chad Henne. The Dolphins continued to maintain their reputation as a run first team (5th most rush attempts per game in the NFL), and managed to be effective as well as they ranked 10th in yards/rush attempt. The passing game left something to be desired, 23rd in the NFL in yards/pass attempt, however they were a very poor defensive unit which was a big reason that they struggled. They allowed the 8th most PPG in the NFL, and although they were only slightly below average against the run, they ranked 28th in the NFL against the pass.

As far as addressing weaknesses goes, the acquisition of WR Brandon Marshall was a great start to fixing the passing game for the Dolphins as he's currently one of the best receivers in the game. With Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams returning at RB, and Marshall now joining this offense, the Dolphins should improve upon the #23 ranking in PPG last season. The problem I see for the Dolphins in 2010 is that it looks like their defense has taken a step back from 2009, a big issue considering it's struggles noted above. They've lost Joey Porter and Jason Taylor, raising some questions as to who will step up at the Linebacker position this season for them. This duo accounted for 15.5 of the team's 44 sacks last season, and I have a hard time believing that their absence won't be felt. In their secondary, the Dolphins really haven't added any new guys, so how does this pass defense see a dramatic improvement? In the end I see the defense being too much of a liability for this team, and although the offense should improve the Dolphins are in for a mediocre 2010. Save your money and stay away from picking them to win the division, as 3-1 odds offer no value whatsoever.

Projected Record: 8-8

Total Play: NO PLAY

* New England Patriots

* Win Line: 9.5

* Odds to win division: +125 (1.25-1)

The Patriots were one of the more inconsistent teams in the league in 2009, winning the AFC East with a 10-6 record before getting blown out in round 1 of the playoffs. There's no doubt injuries hurt this team down the stretch, but if you look at their entire regular season their best win of the season was quite possibly against the Ravens in Week 4, and in that game one of the Ravens' wide receivers dropped the would be winning touchdown. The Patriots beat a lot of teams that really just weren't that good, and struggled to get the job done against the better teams in the league. Of course, a big part of this can be attributed to Brady coming off of his knee injury and struggling to find consistency all year. But have the Pats made the right moves for 2010 to keep their hold on top of the AFC East?

Obviously, Brady should be a bit more comfortable this year another year removed from his knee injury. He looked like two different Quarterbacks at times last year, and we should see more of the Tom Brady we remember from 2007 this coming year. However, Brady will have a tough time as he'll likely be without Welker for the beginning of the season, and although the Patriots added Holt at WR, I'm not sure he has much left to offer in the NFL. The Patriots' rushing game was abysmal last season, ranking 26th in the NFL in yards per rush attempt, and they've done absolutely nothing to fix that this season. The Patriots also ranked poorly in pass and rush defense, however they managed to keep the damage minimal as they ranked 6th in the NFL in points allowed per game. This season, the loss of Jarvis Green could hurt this unit and I expect the Patriots to allow a few more points per game than last year, while defensive yardage allowed stays about the same. When it comes down to it, the Patriots are a team that wins through the air. With that being what the Jets specialize in shutting down, a sweep of the Patriots this season would not surprise me at all (Welker was the key piece in last year's win for the Pats, who knows what kind of shape he'll be in after he returns). Combined with a much tougher schedule than last year, I think the Patriots come up short this season in the AFC East.

Projected Record: 9-7

Total Play: NO PLAY

* New York Jets

* Win Line: 9.5

* Odds to win division: +140 (1.4-1)

In 2009, the Jets were pretty much handed a playoff spot as the Colts and Bengals both mailed in games against them, leaving them with a 9-7 record. The team was phenomenal on defense, as they were the #1 passing defense and #5 rushing defense in the league, and on offense they were the #6 rushing offense. The biggest issue for the Jets was the passing game, as rookie QB Mark Sanchez had a very ugly stretch of games in the middle of the season in which he threw most of his interceptions. Ultimately the Jets lost in the AFC Championship game to the Colts, as Peyton Manning proved too much for the defense to overcome.

The Jets enter the 2010 season with lofty expectations, deservedly so in my opinion. The pass defense looks to have improved, hard to believe given their #1 ranking last year, but the addition of Cromartie and Wilson give the Jets three amazing cornerbacks. Not only that, but the defense has also added Jason Taylor from the Dolphins, and will have Kris Jenkins returning from an ACL tear last season. This will be an elite unit once again, and probably the best defense in the league. The questions the Jets have to answer are on offense. You have to think that Sanchez will improve from last year, he showed flashes of potential throughout the season and put a few great games together. He also gave a few away by failing to take care of the ball and struggling with accuracy, but I believe he will have less games like that this season. Santonio Holmes will give him one more weapon to work with (after his suspension ends), and the Jets now have one of the deeper WR corps in the NFL with Edwards and Cotchery behind him. There are also some questions about whether or not the running game can be as effective without Thomas Jones, but from what I saw last year Greene was a much more effective back and Tomlinson should be able to help take some of the load off. Although Tomlinson may not be the great RB he once was, he will certainly do more in New York than he did behind the awful offensive line he had to play behind last year. The Jets are the class of the AFC East and possibly the NFL, although there is always the possibility of a team like the Colts that could topple them because they have so many weapons on offense. However, not crossing the Colts in the regular season and with a lot of teams on their schedule that rely heavily on the pass, I think the Jets can get off to a hot start and cruise to the AFC East title.

Projected Record: 11-5

Total Play: OVER 9.5

One final note, betting both the Jets and the Patriots to win the East will very likely result in a small profit, as I feel like you can count out the Dolphins and Jets. With the odds at +140 and +125, a bet on each would be the safest approach. I'm sticking with my gut and going with the Jets however, so here's a recap of all my picks this writeup:

Jets OVER 9.5

Bills UNDER 5.5

Jets to win AFC East +140

Good luck to anyone who makes any plays!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can't agree with the idea that the Dolphins' D took a step back this offseason.

Losing 2 guys past their prime is not that big of an issue.

Mike Nolan is now running the defense.

The draft was D heavy.

Davis and Smith have another offseason of experience at the CB position.

My only worry is the safety position right now, but we'll see what happens there.

I also don't understand why the Patriots are favorites in this division. I see them 3rd.

 
Can't agree with the idea that the Dolphins' D took a step back this offseason.

Losing 2 guys past their prime is not that big of an issue.

Mike Nolan is now running the defense.

The draft was D heavy.

Davis and Smith have another offseason of experience at the CB position.

My only worry is the safety position right now, but we'll see what happens there.

I also don't understand why the Patriots are favorites in this division. I see them 3rd.
:lmao: Only surefire thing is Buffalo is last.

 
New England 11-5

NY Jets 10-6...wildcard

Miami 8-8...schedule is brutal for them again, 2nd year QB...they are getting better

Buffalo 4-12...sounds about right

 
New England 11-5NY Jets 10-6...wildcardMiami 8-8...schedule is brutal for them again, 2nd year QB...they are getting betterBuffalo 4-12...sounds about right
Miami at Buffalo Buffalo at Green Bay Buffalo at New England New York Jets at Buffalo Jacksonville at Buffalo Buffalo at Baltimore Buffalo at Kansas City Chicago at Buffalo Detroit at Buffalo Buffalo at Cincinnati Pittsburgh at Buffalo Buffalo at Minnesota Cleveland at Buffalo Buffalo at Miami New England at Buffalo Buffalo at New York Jets Curious to know what 4 games you think Buffalo will win?
 
New England 11-5

NY Jets 10-6...wildcard

Miami 8-8...schedule is brutal for them again, 2nd year QB...they are getting better

Buffalo 4-12...sounds about right
Miami at Buffalo...the Phins usually split with these guysBuffalo at Green Bay

Buffalo at New England

New York Jets at Buffalo...again the Bills don't usually go 0-6 in the division

Jacksonville at Buffalo...road game for a FLorida team, never good.

Buffalo at Baltimore

Buffalo at Kansas City...competitive

Chicago at Buffalo...turnover machine called Cutler

Detroit at Buffalo

Buffalo at Cincinnati

Pittsburgh at Buffalo

Buffalo at Minnesota

Cleveland at Buffalo

Buffalo at Miami

New England at Buffalo

Buffalo at New York Jets

Curious to know what 4 games you think Buffalo will win?
I find at least 7 games they will be competitive in and could easily win...4 is pretty good. They could go 2-14, sure but they usually are not the absolute drudge of the league despite always missing the playoffs. And I hate the Bills but I'm just being honest.
 
Miami 8-8...schedule is brutal for them again, 2nd year QB...they are getting better
wow - and your a Miami fan?Year 3 of the rebuild and I'm expecting to make the playoffs for the reasons Trey mentioned earlier - first time in a long time I've had these expectations.
 
New England 11-5

NY Jets 10-6...wildcard

Miami 8-8...schedule is brutal for them again, 2nd year QB...they are getting better

Buffalo 4-12...sounds about right
Miami at Buffalo...the Phins usually split with these guysBuffalo at Green Bay

Buffalo at New England

New York Jets at Buffalo...again the Bills don't usually go 0-6 in the division

Jacksonville at Buffalo...road game for a FLorida team, never good.

Buffalo at Baltimore

Buffalo at Kansas City...competitive

Chicago at Buffalo...turnover machine called Cutler

Detroit at Buffalo

Buffalo at Cincinnati

Pittsburgh at Buffalo

Buffalo at Minnesota

Cleveland at Buffalo

Buffalo at Miami

New England at Buffalo

Buffalo at New York Jets

Curious to know what 4 games you think Buffalo will win?
I find at least 7 games they will be competitive in and could easily win...4 is pretty good. They could go 2-14, sure but they usually are not the absolute drudge of the league despite always missing the playoffs. And I hate the Bills but I'm just being honest.
Fair enough, can't really argue with any of that. If I was a betting man I'd bet 4 or under rather than 5 or above. I think 2-4 in the division is optimistic.
 
New England 11-5

NY Jets 10-6...wildcard

Miami 8-8...schedule is brutal for them again, 2nd year QB...they are getting better

Buffalo 4-12...sounds about right
Miami at Buffalo...the Phins usually split with these guysBuffalo at Green Bay

Buffalo at New England

New York Jets at Buffalo...again the Bills don't usually go 0-6 in the division

Jacksonville at Buffalo...road game for a FLorida team, never good.

Buffalo at Baltimore

Buffalo at Kansas City...competitive

Chicago at Buffalo...turnover machine called Cutler

Detroit at Buffalo

Buffalo at Cincinnati

Pittsburgh at Buffalo

Buffalo at Minnesota

Cleveland at Buffalo

Buffalo at Miami

New England at Buffalo

Buffalo at New York Jets

Curious to know what 4 games you think Buffalo will win?
I find at least 7 games they will be competitive in and could easily win...4 is pretty good. They could go 2-14, sure but they usually are not the absolute drudge of the league despite always missing the playoffs. And I hate the Bills but I'm just being honest.
Fair enough, can't really argue with any of that. If I was a betting man I'd bet 4 or under rather than 5 or above. I think 2-4 in the division is optimistic.
It's even better than that for the under, the line is 5.5, so they'd have to go 6-10 for you to lose. I am a betting man and I will be taking that under line.
 
Can't agree with the idea that the Dolphins' D took a step back this offseason.Losing 2 guys past their prime is not that big of an issue.Mike Nolan is now running the defense.The draft was D heavy.Davis and Smith have another offseason of experience at the CB position.My only worry is the safety position right now, but we'll see what happens there.I also don't understand why the Patriots are favorites in this division. I see them 3rd.
:rolleyes: but you forgot Dansby.
 
Miami 8-8...schedule is brutal for them again, 2nd year QB...they are getting better
wow - and your a Miami fan?Year 3 of the rebuild and I'm expecting to make the playoffs for the reasons Trey mentioned earlier - first time in a long time I've had these expectations.
Really?Defense: Front 7 is a work in progress still. Crowder and Dansby isnide, Koa Misi and Cameron Wade at OLB...I'm not confident in a rookie and ex CFL player starting on the outside...where are we gettign a pass rush from exactly? The DBs were rookies last year and will get better but this is still a very young group with not a lot at one of the Safety positions. On offense, it's good along the OL, brough in Marshall, but Ronnie can't finish a season, Ricky is 32, most of the WR are pretty young. 2nd year QB starting...Compare Miami vs Baltimore, NY Jets, New England, San Diego, Indy...where does Miami fit in for the 2010 playoffs? Unless NE and NY collapse somehow I don't see Miami winning the division or having enough wins to be a wildcard. We still need a lot of pieces. But we were 1-15 in 2007/2008 so we are getting better quickly but we need more, we're not there yet. The playoffs in 2008 were unfortunate in many ways as fans thought we were a lot closer than we were.
 
Now this is what I call quality reading while procrastonating at work. Nice write up!
Thank you sir!
Curious to know what 4 games you think Buffalo will win?
Cleveland, Detroit, Jacksonville, KC are all winnable, best case scenario I think they win 3 of those. I figure they may steal one game otherwise in division or against someone like the Bears. The line being at 5.5 is great because even if they steal two it still goes under.
Hey, Koy, like your stuff here and at Rx, can you link to previous threads?
AFC WestAFC North

 
2 Things:

1) Unfortunately the Pats deserve more love.... Most everything starts and finishes with the QB and New England has BY FAR the best QB in the division. They have thier #1 WR now healthy and as good as anyone else in the division now with Brandon Marshall potentially close.... On defense, they still have "The Genius" so I'm not counting that defense out and IMO, last year was more of the transition year for the defense where now they have a few more pieces.

2) MIAMI....

Interesting article in the Miami Herald.... I'll just say, a lot of this I've been saying since the end of last year - Again, if it starts at the QB position, Henne has a lot more experience than Sanchez. The Offensive weapons are similiar and then it all comes down to the defense and IMO, Miami looks to be building a decent defense...

As a Jets fan, I don't hate the expectations but, as a Football fan I also know that an NFL season relies heavily on staying healthy... Jets have transitions at RB, The OL, and Sanchez needs to take a big step....

Regardless, Miami took 2 games from NY last year and there's no way they can be overlooked as a team WAY behind the Jets or something... To me, it's a pretty evenly matched Heavyweight battle...

I will say this - Kris Jenkins is a MONSTER and IMO one of the best defensive players in the NFL when healthy.... The Jets did what they did last year mostly without him - If he can play and now rotate with what they developed last year, things could actually tale another step up form what they already acomplished.

Also, that article notes that the Jets are so desperate for a DE they are converting Gholston to DE - that's ridiculous - the Jets DE spot is a hold the fort spot that Ryan usually finds a player to fill - The Gholston move is simply Gholston's last chance to rotate in somewhere and contribute at all... the two issues have zero ties.

But, decent stuff to debate in the article:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Herald

Miami Dolphins, Jets similarly matched despite offseason boasts

BY ARMANDO SALGUERO

They're beating the Super Bowl drums in New Jersey because the Jets have a wonderfully entertaining big mouth for a coach, an aggressive front office and a star-studded roster that suggests the team that fell in the conference title game last season can take the next step this season.

In Miami, no one is boasting. There are no Super Bowl dreams at night, and the days are filled with the usual silence from Bill Parcells and Jeff Ireland and Tony Sparano.

At some point this offseason, Sparano might go out on a limb and predict the Dolphins will show up for their 2010 games.

So the approaches the Jets and Dolphins are taking are vastly different.

The expectation for each team is different. The vibe around the two teams is, you guessed it, different.

And that should not be.

I'm here to tell you that somebody -- either the Jets or Dolphins or the media covering them -- is making a terrible mistake in judgment because these two teams are practically mirror images of each other.

The two teams look similar on the field, have similar philosophies on offense and defense and, most importantly, have similar strengths, weaknesses and talent.

So, either the Jets are overestimating their worth. Or we're badly underestimating the Dolphins.

CLEAR ADVANTAGE

Study the starting lineups for the Jets and Dolphins. There are places the Jets enjoy a clear talent advantage:

At cornerback, Darrelle Revis and Antonio Cromartie get the nod over Vontae Davis and Sean Smith based on experience, performance and the fact that Revis is inarguably the NFL's best at his position.

The nod at outside linebacker also has to go to the Jets because they signed Jason Taylor away from the Dolphins and he, Calvin Pace and Bryan Thomas are more seasoned than Miami's likely combination of Cameron Wake, Koa Misi or perhaps Charlie Anderson.

The Jets also hold an advantage at tight end, where Dustin Keller has been more productive than Miami starter Anthony Fasano over the past two years.

But that's where the advantage for the supposedly Super Bowl-bound Jets ends.

The Dolphins, meanwhile, have better running backs, with Ricky Williams, Ronnie Brown and Patrick Cobbs having proved themselves over the years and showing no sign of aging.

The Jets have Shonn Greene, who is an unknown quantity or quality, and former star LaDainian Tomlinson, whose recent statistics speak of a player in decline.

The Dolphins are better established and deeper at defensive end with Kendall Langford, Tony McDaniel and Phillip Merling about to get a boost from first-round pick Jared Odrick.

Sure, the Jets have a good player in Shaun Ellis, but the Jets will need two defensive ends in 2010, and New York's other starter is a question mark.

The Jets are so desperate for defensive end help they moved outside linebacker Vernon Gholston there, hoping he can contribute. A 263-pound bust linebacker as a 3-4 defensive end?

Good luck with that.

Miami's Yeremiah Bell, a Pro Bowl player, is bigger, stronger, faster and simply better than Jim Leonhard at strong safety.

Miami kicker Dan Carpenter is better than New York's Nick Folk because Carpenter went to the Pro Bowl last year, and Folk missed 10 field goals -- three more than Carpenter has missed in two years.

The Dolphins own talent advantages over the Jets, just as New York holds some over Miami.

The rest of the starting lineups, meanwhile, suggest no clear advantage to either team.

New Yorkers think second-year starter Mark Sanchez is going to be a star quarterback. And he might develop into one, so no argument there.

But Miamians think Chad Henne, in his second-year as the starter, is similarly going to be a star quarterback.

New York's offensive line is very good except for that left guard spot, where Alan Faneca struggled last year and is gone with no certain replacement on the scene. Miami's offensive line is similarly good except for that left guard spot where Justin Smiley struggled last year and is likely gone with his replacement yet to be identified.

VERY RELIABLE

The Jets love Tony Richardson at fullback, and Miami's Lousaka Polite is every bit his equal.

Yes, Bart Scott and David Harris are very good inside linebackers. So are Miami's Karlos Dansby and Channing Crowder.

Both the Jets and Dolphins must find a reliable starting free safety because neither team can guarantee the players currently vying for the job are long-term answers.

The nose tackle position is interesting on both rosters because New York's Kris Jenkins is coming off an injury and is just one good meal shy of 400 pounds. Miami is addressing the nose tackle spot by moving Randy Starks from defensive end and hoping he can adjust quickly and smoothly.

So both teams are investing equal amounts of faith that their nose tackle solutions will hold.

Last season, the Jets had a better wide receiver corps than the Dolphins. Come to think of it, the University of Miami had a better wide receiver corps than the Dolphins.

But the addition of Pro Bowl player Brandon Marshall and expected maturation of Brian Hartline evens Miami's receivers with New York's -- even following New York's addition of Santonio Holmes when he's done with his, ahem, drug suspension.

Obviously, the comparison of offensive lines or linebacker corps is an offseason fancy because come this fall, Miami's linebackers will not face New York's linebackers.

But the comparison of talent should be an eye-opener. The teams are pretty much equals, and the only separation between them might come from injuries or weather or other twists of fate.

As for today, if the Jets are a Super Bowl contender, so are the Dolphins. If the Dolphins are just pretenders, so are the Jets.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top